You will increase the surface are much more by using cloths and sponges. The humidity wick pads do even better.I have increased the surface area by adding a snap-on lid which is about 8" x 6" in area, but still the humidity won't go past 40%! It's the styrofoam that is absorbing the humidity and passing it though to the outside, that is the problem.
Bead board has a limit to how much moisture it can absorb. If your humidity is not increasing then you may have a faulty hygrometer, too much air leakage, or just have not increased the water surface area sufficiently.