Is it possible that Ideal Poultry is scam artists?

bigboykh

In the Brooder
Nov 22, 2023
7
13
21
Potential scenario with Ideal Poultry posted for a family member who needs advice:

We decided that we wanted to raise baby chickens. We ordered 30 baby chickens from Ideal Poultry. We paid extra for them to be all pullets but they were also on sale. I don't remember the exact price but it was around $1.00 off per bird so they were around $3.50. For the sake of me not remembering, we are going to say they were $3.50 each which is very close to accurate. Weeks later, they run the same sale and we purchase 60 more. It did not take but a few months for use to realize that they were almost all roosters. We contacted Ideal Poultry who said that it was impossible to tell until they were at least 16 weeks old. They told us, if we did get more than 90% roosters, they would refund the difference between the price of a rooster and hen which is roughly 75 cents per bird. I was not happy. At 16 weeks old, these are clearly 95% roosters--both sets of them. I contact Ideal Poultry. They will not refund any money. Even I paid full price for the birds, it would be less than $1 per bird for a refund. I got them on sale for the same price that the roosters were originally so I get no money back. I ask for a replacement of birds and that is not their policy. Apparently you agree to this policy when you buy birds from them. I bet that it has cost me $20 per bird to raise these babies for them to be all roosters. I have fed them medicated chick starter at $25-28 per bag. I have 90 chickens and they are 95% roosters. They are not selling very well even at $5 each and we are slowly giving them all away--minus the few hens. We feel like we have been scammed: they were able to sell us almost 90 roosters and get full price for them from us. We are out tons of dollars on feeding these birds. We are so upset that we are considering consulting a lawyer after the holidays. Not sure that it would do any good but we are at least going to get his advice.
 
I’m sorry for how many roosters you got but there is not a 100% guarantee
that you’ll get pullets when you order them as chicks. I don’t think you should completely blame the company for how many Roos you got. It would of been nice of them to give you a replacement order or refund some money but they are a business and they have their own birds that they have to feed.
Have you tried putting your roosters on your local Craigslist?
 
I’m sorry for how many roosters you got but there is not a 100% guarantee
that you’ll get pullets when you order them as chicks. I don’t think you should completely blame the company for how many Roos you got. It would of been nice of them to give you a replacement order or refund some money but they are a business and they have their own birds that they have to feed.
Have you tried putting your roosters on your local Craigslist?
Most hatcheries do guarantee at least 90% females though so to get 90% males is the complete opposite of that and absolutely UNACCEPTABLE so they should do SOMETHING. However, that said, I do NOT believe they are a scam. They are a very reputable company who has been in business many years and I had excellent luck with them. Got exactly what I ordered and even an extra bird. OP just had terrible luck it seems. But I can’t believe they won’t at least refund the money. Although it kind of seems like they wanted to do a partial refund and OP refused as they felt it wasn’t enough???? If so, that’s not the company’s fault and doesn’t make them a scam.
 
I’m sorry for how many roosters you got but there is not a 100% guarantee
that you’ll get pullets when you order them as chicks. I don’t think you should completely blame the company for how many Roos you got. It would of been nice of them to give you a replacement order or refund some money but they are a business and they have their own birds that they have to feed.
Have you tried putting your roosters on your local Craigslist?

Most hatcheries do guarantee at least 90% females though so to get 90% males is the complete opposite of that and absolutely UNACCEPTABLE so they should do SOMETHING. However, that said, I do NOT believe they are a scam. They are a very reputable company who has been in business many years and I had excellent luck with them. Got exactly what I ordered and even an extra bird. OP just had terrible luck it seems. But I can’t believe they won’t at least refund the money. Although it kind of seems like they wanted to do a partial refund and OP refused as they felt it wasn’t enough???? If so, that’s not the company’s fault and doesn’t make them a scam.
 
I believe that both of you might be having a little trouble comprehending my post. I wrote on here that I was trying to sell them for $5 each and they were not selling. I also wrote that they were going to offer me a difference in the price between female and male and that was about 75 cents a bird but they declined since I got the birds on sale. I wrote all this in the post. 95% roosters is far from acceptable and there should be a legal route to take. They should not be able to sell them to me at a premium price and at all girls yes and almost all boys. Something is not adding up.
 
Apparently I am not alone
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-05-05.png
    Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-05-05.png
    210.4 KB · Views: 24
  • Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-09-27.png
    Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-09-27.png
    183.7 KB · Views: 27
  • Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-10-39.png
    Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-10-39.png
    194.8 KB · Views: 26
  • Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-14-19.png
    Screenshot_2023-11-22-23-14-19.png
    214.4 KB · Views: 24
Do you have the confirmation e-mail or packing list?

It is pretty common to MEAN to select pullets and inadvertently hit straight run or males.
Good point.

Most often, Ideal's sales are just for females or straight run, without the option of all males. That makes it less likely that someone would select all males by mistake (but it could still happen.)
 
Good point.

Most often, Ideal's sales are just for females or straight run, without the option of all males. That makes it less likely that someone would select all males by mistake (but it could still happen.)

I have seen a few this year that the sales were all males and a few that had options.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom