I have a bit of a dilemma.. I've got 3 roosters and they've gotten along fine until they were a year old. I have a good rooster whom comes running at any sound of distress from the hens. A mean one whom attacks me when my back is turned, then runs away when I face him. And a "child friendly" one who is quiet and never hurts anyone.
I can't have the two fighting and all of them over mating with the hens but I'm kind of attached to them. I'm unsure of how to handle it
I am not a culling person but you can't have a nasty rooster around. If you can find someone to take him and be an only rooster he may be nicer but you have to accept that if he isn't he may become dinner for someone else. If you can't do that there are places that will "process" a bird for a fee. The other 2 if getting along now will probably continue to get along.
I ended up with 2 roos because they were both nice and I hated to see one go to freezer camp when he didn't need to. Big Boy is in charge and Handsome follows. I have seen them work together to protect the girls. If things go south and they start fighting I'll have to deal with it then.
Good Luck. (I used 2 roosters as an excuse to get more hens.