I like orps and am tempted but I have issues distinguishing them from my jersey giant chicks
Have you tried hatching baskets and toe punching the chicks? Below is what we use. The basket fits in a Genesis by Hovabator. We have the following varieties of Orpingtons at the same time: Black, BBS, Self Blue/Splits, Gold Laced. All can hatch Black. We then toe punch and place them in the same brooder. We actually toe punch about everything.
We found, if only ordering a toe punch, Strombergs had the best total price. That's cost plus shipping.
So grab the Orp eggs, use a hatching basket (available at most Wal-Marts) and buy a toe punch! Lets get this thread moving!
http://www.rubbermaid.com/Category/Pages/ProductDetail.aspx?Prod_ID=RP091308
http://www.strombergschickens.com/product/2348/toe-punch
http://www.dominiquechicken.com/Toe_Punch_Chart.html