Well, one good thing about him, when he scratches around, he sure does till up the ground. ha,ha,ha. I might keep him just for that reason. In all seriousness, I've been watching this one for a long time. I really like the bulkiness of him. A couple of them are really brick shaped but don't have the width that I'm looking for in the backs.I think I'd make an exception and live with the extras toes if it were me....