Okay, so here’s what the farm supply store said when I asked about her:
So sorry to hear that! We use Hoovers Hatchery in Iowa, and the only black chickens we order from them are Black Australorps and Midnight Majesty Marans. They don’t even offer the black Sumatra for us to order as far as we...
My previous Australorps all laid dark brown eggs.
My other three hens currently are Gold Star, Rhode Island Red, and Speckled Sussex. All brown eggs and I’ve witnessed all of them laying brown eggs...
I’ve never had a pea comb hen before, but it’s most certainly not a full comb. It’s about half the size. Yes I agree under her feet are whitish/yellowish. A Jersey Giant? I’ll have to google some pics ;)
I couldn’t catch her, but I got some pics as best I could. She’s got pinkish, mottled feet underneath. Definitely not all black under there. Her comb is very strange. I tried to get a close up. All my other girls the same age have full red combs. She’s just got a little pink nub.
I’ll try it get some more pics of her today if I can catch her ;)
I agree, unlikely that she’s rare. I’d just chalk it up to “hatchery quality,” except for the cream eggs and the fact that we have always used hatchery chicks and have never had such an anomaly.