Search results for query: *

  1. Your_neighbor

    Michigan Right to Farm Law, what does it mean?

    The law could be interpreted to imply that you can put a farm anywhere you want but so technically you may be correct The courts are not implementing it that way, so it is just a technical point. The courts are consistently approaching their cases in the "inferential and speculative" manner I...
  2. Your_neighbor

    Michigan Right to Farm Law, what does it mean?

    "What the Court said here was that the issue of whether or not the plaintiff had the right to extend the farm onto the new land was not raised or was not preserved on appeal. Therefor, the Court would not rule on it. " Agreed. My point is that the court was saying this can be an issue in the...
  3. Your_neighbor

    Michigan Right to Farm Law, what does it mean?

    This sentence in your post is the one I am referring to: "Assuming that the plaintiffs' acquisition of additional land entitled them under the city's zoning ordinance [733 N.W.2d 398] to make agricultural use of the north parcel (a point on which we express no opinion)... The ruling is short...
  4. Your_neighbor

    Michigan Right to Farm Law, what does it mean?

    "3. Troy vs Papadelis (2007 Michigan Supreme Court) Nice statement by court in ruling that implies if farm not legally created then their ruling doesn't apply. SAYS NOTHING EVEN RESEMBLING THAT " Uh...yes, they did. It is the statement starting with "Assuming".
  5. Your_neighbor

    Michigan Right to Farm Law, what does it mean?

    Court rulings both before and after the amendment were listed. The courts interpretations were clear and consistent before and after the amendment if people actually take the time to READ the rulings, which almost nobody bothered to do. The Supreme Court also chimed in after the amendment went...
  6. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Wbanka and others, This may help clarify the issue. these articles and legal opinions, all saying the same thing I am saying, are all over the internet. http://web5.msue.msu.edu/lu/pamphlet/AgrHandBook/PlnZanimalAg30-Ch3.pdf The preemption of local zoning ordinances that conflict with the...
  7. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    ...fact that we daily measure the distance to the moon to a precision of inches using lasers and reflectors left on the surface by the astronauts. I am simply asking if your opinions have any basis in fact (removed by Staff--First rule of BYC* Be friendly and courteous to all members at all times.)
  8. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    In four months Noon made $14. Not $14 profit, FOURTEEN DOLLARS. No wonder the judge said he didn't qualify as commercial! http://www.wxyz.com/dpp/news/region/oakland_county/senior-citizen-fights-village-officials-over-chicken-coop He spent $3500 on the hen house AFTER he was told his...
  9. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    The Ann Arbor Chicken Statute. EXTREMELY well thought out. Multiple protections from RTFA abuse built in. There is a reasonable timing out of permit (5 years). No structure within 10 feet of a property line. Must get all neighbors written permission if not siting at least 40 feet from any...
  10. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Quote: I will keep you posted via Private Message. Am getting ready to move on to other "stuff" as I believe I now fully understand the legal issues. Unless someone can come up with some sort of court case conflicting with the precedents I have posted, it appears the response of any court...
  11. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Quote: Thank goodness! Somebody gets it! Impressive analogy.
  12. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    I have cases supporting my opinions, which are based on those cases. Our opinions are in direct contradiction. Do you have any cases supporting your opinions? Do you have ANY legal basis for supporting your opinion? I think the answer is probably no but I am asking. If not, why are you...
  13. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    OK, we are playing poker and you guys just called by saying I was just voicing my opinion. I have shown my hand through court cases with clear wording. I wasn't bluffing. My opinions are actually the courts opinions. Anyone who can read pretty much has to agree at this point. My hand is...
  14. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    "Neighbor, you can't have it both ways. If court cases set precedents, which you have made clear is the case, then when the courts decide to have their interpretation "bent" they are setting a precedence. If it is so clear cut, they should have followed previous precedence. It is pretty clear...
  15. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    "So, just because people disagree with your opinion and the courts' means they're illiterate?" Some people aren't disagreeing with what the courts have said. They are indicating the courts didn't say it. Some people here are in a remarkable state of denial about what the courts have said...
  16. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Quote: Then you haven't looked in the right place, which is the actual judgements. I have posted several already. The actual rulings are easily obtained online. I am no longer sure of everyone's reading ability so I will just post the information for each person to do their own research...
  17. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    "Have you actually determined whether your neighbor is actually following GAAMPS? Is she is, then her birds should not normally be odorous--maybe after a long wet and rainy spell, but not on a regular, constant basis. It seems to me that that is your actual best best at re-gaining the pleasure...
  18. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Quote: I agree that is your stated opinion, but I have yet to see a judgement that explicitly said that. Then you haven't looked in the right place, which is the actual judgements. I have posted several already. The actual rulings are easily obtained online. I am no longer sure of...
  19. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Quote: Your words make only your opinions clear. If you want to make the courts opinion clear you have to quote the exact language of the court documents. The opinion of the courts is in their documents, not in your posts. This isn't rocket science. Folks contributing to the original RTF...
  20. Your_neighbor

    Update: (City Oppression) Milford tickets 93 year old man for hens

    Not quite. Please read this very carefully because there are some extremely important concepts here. If you follow them I suspect we will be more or less in agreement. My position has always been that cities aren't allowing small backyard farms because they don't want RTFA to strip their...
Back
Top Bottom