Unfortunately we live in an area where free roaming chickens are not feasible.
We don't have the tree coverage others have. We live on ten acres with free roaming coyotes which are always on the hunt for something to eat. There are no stray cats or neighborhood dogs looking for a water bowl or...
Fluffy,
Are your chickens yard ornament chickens, kept for meat or eggs? Five roosters is a lot, if Jack is normally a good producer of what ever trait you are breeding for then compare the offspring from #2 Wade and keep the one with the best production results.
BG,
How old are your hens, do they all lay in the same box, how large are the nesting boxes? Most likely you have one egg eater, once the egg is broken they all clean-up.