We ended up not keeping 2 of the blue/black ones, one is definitely a hen that we did keep, my favorite blueish one, the white one is most definitely a roo.
The other two just had bad attitudes so I didn't think we needed them in our flock!
Thank you! I am, too. We may have lucked out on these and some chocolate orpingtons and actually got all pullets! Usually a roo sneaks in there it seems!
What about the tail feathers?? The one I thought was the only hen has different tail feathers than the other 3. It's point down more than their straight up. Does that make a difference?
We hatched these four 2 months ago and are trying to figure out which are hens and which are roosters.. They are Americana hens X a Cinnamon Queen rooster. Really hoping the one I think is a hen is... 1&2 I think are roos, and #3 I'm not at all sure!
Thank you!!