According to Japanese silkie site, The Original silkie were found in China & Japan used to have 5, 6, sometimes 7 toes. And Extra toes were more common silkies back of the time. And now Japanese & Chinese think Extra toes silkies are more special.(not in the U.S.A, though) Which means you still...
I'll also go with No.3. You dont wanna keep mean personality one. No.2 looks great too, but, red comb. No.3 has mulberry comb & feather feet. love the gold color around his neck! He's just gorgeous! Noriko.