@Ryebi, my comment about using care when looking for Pilgrims was just directed to folks who are new to the breed in a general sense, not you, specifically. 🙂
That's disheartening that you encountered so many with issues that could have been easily prevented and/or addressed. There's plenty of...
I also raise Pilgrims. It must be certain lines that experience the low fertility because mine don't have that issue (I've set 4 hatches this year so far). My stock is from both reasonably local shipped eggs and local (as in close enough to drive to) stock, rather than direct-from-hatchery...