Thank you for the input, one chick two and cocoamarley! Will keep an eye on the lititle guy. No hackles or saddle feathers yet but I'm sure it won't be long.
Here's an update on the questionable chick, Richard Sherman. The original verdict was cockerel from experts here.
I've been told that Marans from Cackle mature early and look scary/roostery at an early age, but I've got my doubts still.
No crowing yet, and I've included a picture of the...
With the level of experience and knowledge that I've seen here, I doubt it, but I guess there's always the chance, Sherman's new home won't be ready to take him until mid-April so I've got some time to spend with the little guy, and the gender will be absolutely unmistakable by then. Will keep...
Thanks everyone! My little rooster has a great home lined up for when he gets a bit bigger. I'll keep him until he starts to crow (or by some miracle, decides to be a pullet, very unlikely). The thing that is throwing me off is that a few days after posting that picture, several of the other...
Speaking of feathered legs, as promised here's more pictures of my questionable chick at just under 4 weeks.
Case for PULLET:
sold as sexed pullet (i know, i know)
developed tail feathers at same rate as other chicks
comb not red
Not mounting or trying to crow at this point
Case for COCKEREL...
Ah, seeing your two side by side, mine certainly does not inspire a lot of confidence in the pullet department, does it? Drat. Thanks for the help everyone! Time to start looking for a new home!
Carcar80,since you've got an eye for this sort of thing and chicks the same age as mine, give this a look please. Here's Sherman next to a Gold Comet, 12 days old. The comb doesn't look alarming to my untrained eye (it wouldn't at this point anyway, right?), but the upright posture, thick legs...
OK Don! See you back here in a week!
If she was a rooster it wouldn't be the end of the world, there are a lot of people in my area raising chickens who would love to have him. I was so hoping for my colorful egg basket though... I'm kind of fond of the little thing, so much personality...
"Rooster" is the vibe I'm getting too, but I guess time will tell. They are almost 2 w weeks old, at what age should I post a picture for all you experts to weigh in? 4-5 weeks should be pretty clear, right? If she starts crowing at 5 weeks like yours, Chalk then I guess that's pretty...
I've got a BCM chick in with a mixed bag of other chicks and I have to ask: are the chicks simply HUGE or is it just mine (hopefully not a rooster)? The only chick that is keeping up with her in weight is the Australorp who is a greedy piglet. She's the first in line when there are treats...