Shoot. It looks like I am only getting the emails for new threads.
I just went and unwatched those forums and rewatched and made sure I have the message box checked.
I've got everything watched except for the BTS ones.
I am done clicking for today.
I'll give it until sometime tomorrow and then I will undo the watching.
This has got to be the dumbest thing I've done yet.
I'll report back tomorrow with how many emails I got.
I am not about to count them all...