Pancake is the best name ever!! The warm water mash is a good idea too because it's food & water in one... which sounds obvious but it's of the up most importance that the little peeps sty well hydrated. Good hydration enables excellent thermoregulatory development as well as a hardy appetite...
More than likely she's just fine because she IS eating, but she might just be a little finicky?
Have you ever thought of adding a supplement/treat to the feed to make it more interesting? Like crumbled up mealworms or Chickie-Puffs from MyPetChicken.com?
Mine tend to do better when there's...