it does have a big comb for 4 months old .this is why i never get rid of anything i want till it eithers lays or crows.
if your luck is like mine and its your favorite,then its probably a roo.
are you sure of the age on these guys?they are some big birds for 4 months old and laying already.i...
can you post more pics of each one from the side.
i don't see any saddle feathers or tail feathers on the buff to indicate roo but it has rooish hackles.i don't think it is the buff.
does the first black picture have a straight comb?it has the looking of more saddle feathers.
with all this...