I hope this isn't too complicated to read:
All of the chicks I hatched but two so far were pure black, some white fluff and their first set of feathers were black. None of the black chicks had any hint of red, gold or silver at hatching. Not in their fuzz or first set of feathers until they had that first molt.
I have only gotten two females from this pair so far, one is black and has a pair of small tufts. The other female looks like a wild partridge, she is very interesting. I plan to put her with the blue/yellow male.
Of their black brothers, one has grown a lot of red and has blue/white ear lobes. I am fairly certain he should be culled? I welcome opinions on that note. Another is all glossy black but smooth faced. Another is all glossy black with one tuft.
The fourth black brother is the one with the big tufts and he has the gold bleed through. These are all from different hatches, same parents. Last night I noticed this tufty one is going to be larger in body than his older brothers. He is very stout.
I have a smooth rumpless black two week old chick of unknow sex (I am assuming it is a male) and some eggs due to hatch this weekend from the same pair. It is always interesting to see what pops out!