Did you crack them open and determine they were not fertile? Just because an egg doesn't develop doesn't mean it was infertile. There are a number of reasons the embryo doesn't form, one of them being never fertile.
Araucana, as I'm sure you are aware, are notoriously bad breeders (I'm assuming you are using the US rumpless standard) due to the poor anchoring by the rooster from being tail-less. The rooster may have, uhm, had poor aim and poor connection with the hen not providing a "full load."
Also Araucana are notorious for poor development if both parents are tufted as 2 tufting genes are fatal to the chick. (Though embryos, as I understand, die in the shell later on in the process).
So I'm not sure where your eggs were in fertility process. Obviously you want to always set your freshest with day 7 being the earmark for declining fertility in most breeds.
So it may have been poor coverage by the rooster, poor uneven temp in the incubator. or frustratingly an embryo that simply did not develop.
EDITED to add: And if you are using an older rooster, his fertility may be waning such that his sperm has lost some spunk making some of "his" eggs duds.
My thoughts
LofMc