My grandfather and I tested the power here of direct, aged a bit, closeby, and none at all....
We had a compost pile that was in the back of the orchard..... what was there was aged quite a bit as you when down the line with the newest being on the right side.... It was about 8 feet long so we, and the chickens, could flip it and turn it.... We had some thornless blackberries that were in rows and we decided to test them for production... We put some newly gathered poo on one row in rows about 6 inches from the stalks and then watered to smooth it and work it in....
Then we used some of the aged and did the same thing.....
Then we put more of the new and used combined in a flat row about 10-12 inches (shovel width) and then did not water that right away but let the chickens have at it....plus I was out into the grass a bit at that point and knew that the mower would take out whatever did not take to the ground in the next week or so....
Then one row we did nothing ....
The row that did the best by far was the mixed and indirect.... it loaded up the soil with nutrients but did not burn it as it was far enough away from the stalks to overpower the plants. The newly applied did second best with the aged mighty close behind....
The nothing row produced considerably less....we measured the success by number of gallons produced.... going forward, I will always mix new and old together for the best combination as what worked for us there..... At the end of the season we tilled everything under and started all over again...