Take it with a grain of salt. Yes they have all the eggs - so do humans.
By not encouraging laying with lights, you do not save eggs so that they lay longer over the years. If you use lights, you get eggs at this time. But there is very little possibility you will use up all the eggs, even with a perfect care and life. As the body wears with age, or stress, egg laying naturally decrease with or without light. Which is why people sell spent hens.
Mostly - if you use lights, you will get more eggs per year. However, even with lights, chickens lay less eggs the older they get. Spent hens often times will lay eggs, but not feed efficiently as younger birds do.
How many years the bird lives will determine egg laying amounts in the end. Some people think that if they lay more eggs, they wear out faster and die sooner, but I think while there might be a slight effect on that, but there are a lot of variables to account for. Genetics, feed, climate, breed, predators, disease, parasites and just luck.
I don't use lights - I don't have electricity to the coop. I don't think it is a one way is better than the other.
Mrs K