Gender ID please

[dreamerhps]

I think I know, but would like your input on sexing these fluffy butts. The attached pictures posted are pics of each with two views. The two brown ones together, I put two of the left one and then three of the one on right. I am almost positive that is a Roo but the man I gave them too insist all are hens. I think 3 hens and 1 Roo. What are your thoughts?

 

[Frazzemrat1]

How old?
I think both of the red ones are male.

 

[dreamerhps]

How old?
I think both of the red ones are male.

They are almost 4 months

 

[dreamerhps]

How old?
I think both of the red ones are male.

I only put one pic for the red one on the left. I posted wrong. let me try and find the close up of the first red one. Doesn't have the red on the face and the pea comb is small as well as body size to the one I am fairly certain is a roo.

 

[SBFChickenGirl]

I see at least one roo. One or both of the red ones is a roo.

 

[dreamerhps]

Here is the chook on the left. Orange band.

 

[dreamerhps]

Chook on right, superman ( blue band )

 

[SBFChickenGirl]

Orange band is a definite roo. Not sure about blue band.

 

[dreamerhps]

I see at least one roo. One or both of the red ones is a roo.

I posted more pics.. I think the same

 

[SBFChickenGirl]

Look at blue bands neck feathers. If they are pointy, then it is a roo. If they are round, then it is a hen. Do the same thing with the saddle feathers.