Oh My Julie, Those are some gorgeous boys. You have a tough decision to make. Now you have me thinking I need to think about preparing another breeding pen, LOL. I would love to have some of those.
I think the roo in the back looks more balanced and better developed and his comb looks better right now. I also like a heavier bird, and I don't like how the wing tips are drooping on the front bird, but that could be just how he looked at that second. I DO like it when the saddle feathers are long and drape down like that though... decisions, decisions....