Ok, I've got both reds separated (in the milk crates and they're not really happy about it, lol) and given the AL the run of the coop. I did, however, block her access from the roosting box b/c she seemed to be in it ALL the time and that isn't healthy, I don't think; especially on a beautfiul 50+ degree fall day! So I removed the food/water from the roosting box, blocked it and have the 2 reds separated. I've added another food bowl to the coop area and will be adding another water bowl but am waiting until I can get one that's heated before I spend more money on something I'm not going to use for very long. I've also filed the beaks down a little bit on the Reds (talk about unhappy hens?! lol). What I'm wondering is this: if I wait until dark, and the AL is roosting, to add the reds back in, do you think they'll be ok? When I picked up the AL today she seemed pretty thin, which was the primary reason for separating both the reds from her. I want her to be able to eat/drink w/out being harassed, at least for today. Thanks for any input!