Hi Speckledhen,
I totally see where you're coming from.
My flock is the picture of health -- I don't need the government to tell me that. I cull birds that are unhealthy, have never had an infectious disease in my flock (not one with any perceivable symptoms, anyhow), and keep my birds in the best of conditions.
When I began raising Araucanas, I started off thinking I wouldn't want or need to join NPIP or the breed club or any of that stuff.
HOWEVER -- when selling hatching eggs, I had potential buyers decline to bid because I wasn't an NPIP member, or wasn't a member of the breed club. So, in the interest of increasing my market, I joined the Araucana Club and started emailing my dep't of Agriculture to become an NPIP member.
It is a shame that some people abuse the program. But, since I know my birds are healthy, and since I fully intend to follow the "rules," if the NPIP label helps me sell more eggs... I'm all for it, I guess.
In my eyes, it's essentially a credential to hang on the wall and look impressive, y'know?