Keep which one?

[only one lay]

Not breeding for show or type. Like having a roo for look.
It also allows me to view the behavior of my flock a little truer.
live in town and need to reduce noise. and the one roo is about out of tail feathers, have 18 hens in with

Two polish -one asseritive and dominate. one passive and submissive. How do you decide who stays
and who goes?

 

[Spires6]

If you are trying to decide between two polish roosters, I would keep the more passive, submissive one. I have scars from an aggressive polish I used to have. I don't like being attacked when I come in to feed.