Keep that low man rooster, the one that shows you the most respect by staying out of your way. Let your hens be pets, but if you want a rooster, treat him as intact male livestock and don't try to make a pet of him. You want a rooster that doesn't approach you except on your own terms and yields easily to you when you move through the flock.
At a minimum you just need to randomly pull two roosters out of there and give that poor hen a rest. Or pull them all and really give her some peace. This is the reason we don't advise keeping this many roosters per hen, especially when they're so young and horny.