Resetting Eggs Under Broody

Harmony Fowl

Crowing
8 Years
Joined
Jul 17, 2017
Messages
648
Reaction score
1,325
Points
306
Location
Virginia
This has been a terrible summer for my broody hens. I have never had more than two at a time and the past few weeks I've dealt with four simultaneously. Hatch rates have been horrible. The first hen hatched a single chick. The second and third hens, who were sharing that original hen's clutch from where she originally put them in the woods, did not hatch any. I found new chicks for the two mothers and they've taken to parenting them together, very cute.

Today is day 21 for my last broody. She's an experienced mom and I know she does a good job, but still, no sign of chicks. A couple days ago, I thought I heard her clucking to her eggs. I was hopeful this meant babies soon, at least one to satisfy her mothering instinct, but so far nothing. I've never not had chicks from a broody at this point, so I'm almost certain none will hatch. I'm not giving up yet, but by early next week, I will have to decide. I've never broken a broody or seen a reason to. Her desire to raise offspring is (usually) easy enough to accommodate and serves me, too, by growing my flock.

After the trouble of getting chicks once already and not wanting to go through the trouble, expense or contact with other people just now, has anyone ever reset new eggs under a broody if hers failed to hatch? I worry it would be too much. She seems to be in reasonable condition. She is in a private spot in a small coop, so she doesn't have to compete for food with the others. I've been supplementing her with some scrambled egg every day just to be nice. Has anyone tried it? Am I just asking to much and should bite the bullet and find yet more chicks?
 
I would not put her through three more weeks mainly because it is just too darn hot even if she is keeping herself up reasonably well it is still stressful.
Time to start chick hunting my freind it is hard as hades to break one after a few weeks, im living the dream as we speak.
 
Just in case anyone wishes to try it, I thought I'd add what I did and the result for anyone finding themselves in the same situation, so they can decide what to do as I had to. I went ahead and gave her more eggs. So much info goes around that the person giving the advice has never tried. I'm certainly NOT aiming that at you, Chickassan, more at myself. I'd never tried it, so before I blindly follow advice, let me try it so I have the experience myself to say one way or another.

Well, she lasted a long time, but the heat continued. One of her three new eggs vanished. A second I found crushed with a nearly fully formed chick around day 17. By then, she was up. She wasn't going to keep trying. I guess her chicken biology was telling her the hatch was a fail and she needed to move on.

I had eggs running alongside her in the incubator. These also had a bizarre time. Either I got my dates wrong (possible, unlikely, but possible) or the only two chicks to hatch did so on days 23 and 24. I've never had a surviving chick hatch any later than day 22 before. Anyway, the hen was still running around half broody, getting in fights with real broodies, clucking away, so I thought I'd try. I didn't think it likely since she wasn't sitting on the nest, but it was worth a try. Alone in the coop, she at first seemed interested, but never fully approached the two chicks (a day old and hours old, respectively.) She did not move to harm them but would not commit to caring for them. Since they can't sit around safely to wait for her to make up her mind, I removed them and will be raising them inside.

Oh, well. Now I have the experience I was looking for. This has been a crazy summer for chicks. So many broodies, so few chicks. I'm glad the spring was kinder in both respects.
 
I personally would have gotten chicks and put them with her. I would not have tried to start over. I just put 27 eggs in the incubator 2 days before I had yet another hen go broody. Once the eggs in the incubator hatch I be giving a bunch to her.
 
My broody is on her second failed batch and I’m wondering if I should break her or place more eggs under her, she’s been broody for upwards of 30 days. She’s healthy but fall is here soon, will the weather be an issue? I live in BC Canada in zone 5
I would not put her through three more weeks mainly because it is just too darn hot even if she is keeping herself up reasonably well it is still stressful.
Time to start chick hunting my freind it is hard as hades to break one after a few weeks, im living the dream as we speak.
 
I'm inclined to agree with giving her chicks. I would not have attempted a third try hatching eggs. Even if it's a cockerel, she only needs one to make her happy, and if it has a mother, single chicks do fine. If finding someone to take the cockerel once its mother pushes it out is really a problem, I would try and break her.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom