Rooster to hen ratio

StepfordCuckoos

Songster
6 Years
Mar 20, 2019
240
264
166
We originally got 4 chicks from TSC. This was about 1.5 years ago. Having moved from a city to the country, we didn't have a lot of knowledge about chickens. We knew we wanted them though, so we prepared and went to TSC. We got two bantams and two barred rocks- both from straight run bins. Turns out we got 2 roosters and 2 hens (1 silkie roo, 1 silkie hen)(1 barred rock rooster, 1 barred rock hen). A few months later we got four more chickens (this time we ordered them a hatchery, trying our best to make sure they were hens). Our silkie hen was picked on so badly by the other chickens that we put her in the baby chicks (who at this point were not actual small chicks anymore). We then had 2 roosters to our 1 BR hen. That didn't work out. We put our BR hen with the silkie and other chicks. That worked for a bit but then the roosters started fighting so bad that there was blood everywhere. So we took our BR rooster out and put him with the girls. He is very protective of them but he is also very rough.

This left our silkie roo alone. He had been very rough with the girls in the beginning so we didn't think it'd be good for him to have hens. That was probably a year ago. In the meantime we've gotten more chicks (March 31st). Those chicks weren't put in with the Br rooster/hens because as it turns out one of the hens we ordered turned out to be a rooster. So for now, that rooster (Lu) is with them. However, as I mentioned before- our BR rooster is very rough with his girls. He has injured two of our hens. First, the silkie ( he tore her side open when jumping on top of her ) which required her coming inside to get some TLC. Vetericyn healed her up really nicely. She did end up spending almost two months inside though ( she became quite the diva too. her time was spent in my bathroom and in the morning she'd stand at the bathroom gate and scream until I made her her morning eggs ). During that time inside, we did get those new chicks I mentioned previously. She was in the bathroom while they were in the brooder (which is also in the bathroom). They were put outside a while back (or it feels like a while back lol). A few days after we put them out, our silkie girl was ready to go outside. But we knew we weren't going to put her back with our BR roo nor our silkie roo. So we tried her with the baby chicks and it worked perfectly. I don't know if it was because she was used to their noises from the brooder or what it was, but she blends with them perfectly. At night they all crowd up to her for warmth. It's very cute.

Right after she went outside, our cross beaked EE got very sick. We thought we were losing her. We brought her inside fully thinking she wouldn't make it through the night, but she did. We put her on medicine and she spent probably close to a month inside. After she was better she was put back with our BR roo and the other girls. THEN we noticed that our BR hen was missing a lot of feathers on her neck and sides because of the roo. We brought her inside and she spent a little under two weeks in my bathroom. We tried putting her with the newest chickens (the group that our silkie is now with) but that didn't work out. We tried putting her back with the BR roo and he immediately jumped on her and was VERY rough. He kept going after her really violently, so we took her out.

Finally, we tried her with the silkie roo who hadn't been with any hens for over a year. To our surprise, he took to her like a duck to water. For the past two days he's been standing guard near her as she gives herself a dust bath and lays under their coop. He stood next to her for most of the day yesterday and didn't bother her one bit. It surprised me (and the rest of the family) how gentle he's been with her.

This was very long, but there is a question at the end. We have six chicks in a brooder (2 OE, 2 Isa Browns, 2 silkies) and we're wondering whether you all think it would be safe to put them with the two of them when they're old enough. I know it's better to have more hens to one rooster, but he seems to happy with her. Would it disturb the peace to add them there? What do you guys think?
 
What I would do is get rid of the barred rock rooster and keep the silkie. The barred rock rooster does not sound very good for his hens, and the flock would probably be better without him. It also sounds like he wont get along with the silkie. Your silkie roo sounds better for your flock, and you wont need to keep him separate from the others anymore.
 
What I would do is get rid of the barred rock rooster and keep the silkie. The barred rock rooster does not sound very good for his hens, and the flock would probably be better without him. It also sounds like he wont get along with the silkie. Your silkie roo sounds better for your flock, and you wont need to keep him separate from the others anymore.
We don't cull our roosters. People have suggested that but we just can't. He's really nasty and I dislike him greatly (he's attacked me badly) but culling just isn't an option for us. We have debated starting a bachelor flock and making it so that he can't see the girls.
 
So you plan to keep the Rock male in solitary confinement? I'm assuming yes since he is rough with the hens and aggressive towards other males. What do you plan to do with your oops cockerel?
 
We don't cull our roosters. People have suggested that but we just can't. He's really nasty and I dislike him greatly (he's attacked me badly) but culling just isn't an option for us. We have debated starting a bachelor flock and making it so that he can't see the girls.
If you don't want to cull, you could try rehoming him. A bachelor pen or solitary confinement are also a good options. He really just needs to be away from the hens, he doesn't have to be culled.
 
You do not need to keep a rooster, give him to someone else. No one should keep a pet that attacks them, it is not good mentally to take abuse from an animal. However, none of my business, not my chickens not my coop.

I would vote putting the silkies with the silkies and maybe the OE, then tend to be milder birds. I think the Isa browns are a bit more aggressive, and I would not want them with the silkies.

Mrs K
 
don’t listen to the people who said to cull the roosters, i used to have a bachelor flock with my drakes and it worked really well. the only reason we ended up having to rehome some of the boys is because we had a hawk attack, and reintroducing one of our boys after he was indoors for a month disrupted the entire pecking order in the middle of spring.

i would say introduce the boys in a pen so they can see but not touch each other, and slowly let them be together
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom