Their combs are still pretty small, first one is redder but I think still pullet like.
More importantly, they both have fairly even patterning in their feathers. Roos look more like patchwork quilts while pullets are more partridge like and even in their pattern.
Thank!!! I thought they were Americaunas, so was hoping for a roo in there. Now that I know they aren't a true breed, my welsummer roo has been given a stay of execution (olive eggers)! And I was sure the first one was a roo, so now I have 3 EE pullets instead we believe! Guess I don't have Mr and Mrs Oreo anymore!! lol