So, just to update this thread since I have mostly been on the Orp thread rather than posting here... we have ended up losing 10 of the 14 chicks. The last few, 2 of which appear to be about 2-3 weeks old and 2 of which appear to be about a week old (although obviously stunted at this point, so perhaps older), are doing MUCH better. The others just never recovered. They were dead and near dead upon arrival and just slowly succumbed, never rebounding. I think that they were simply too old to ship, mixed ages, and were starved/dehydrated to death. I also certainly can't rule out that something also happened in transit that they were too weak to survive without food and water. Again, there is a reason it is illegal to ship started chicks.
I was reluctant to mention at first that Greenfire had sent me old chicks of different ages (against my consent and the terms of the auction) but, I wanted to see how Greenfire responded first. Basically, at first they tried to only refund for some of the chicks. They refused to admit the chicks were older than a day old and different ages, basically they accepted no fault or wrong doing what so ever. I explained the situation and asked them to put themselves in my shoes and BE FAIR about this. They responded with a refund for all the chicks but one that had died (that one died after the refund or else they probably would have refunded that one too I imagine), but it certainly was not "service with a smile". They were quite curt about it, but I guess I should be thankful for at least getting some of the money back.
I don't know if this whole thing is simply a result of their inexperience (which is what I hope) or if they don't give a darn about the lives' of these animals. I would hope that they would, at some point, make the decision to not knowingly break Federal law in shipping chicks like this that are over 24 hours old. Several BYC'ers have shown me a tremendous amount of moral support and one has sent me links to threads as old as a year and a half ago where Greenfire pulled the same exact thing on two different people (so, take that how you will).
The remaining chicks that are ALL supposedly day-old chicks (well, actually supposedly 5 days old when the pictures were taken)...