The Truth about Egg Quality

Davaroo

Poultry Crank
12 Years
Feb 4, 2007
5,517
127
308
Leesville, SC
Where Does Quality Come From?

Where the heck does quality come from, anyway? One thing that messes up farmers when they're just starting out is that they learned everything they know from advertising campaigns. They think that the secret is to have 100% natural, organically certified, union-made, grass-fed, hand-picked, fat-free, vitamin-fortified, UL-approved, celebrity-endorsed, grade A food made with post-consumer ingredients -- as seen on TV.


In short, everybody and his brother is bombarding consumers with dumbed-down and largely untrue messages about where quality comes from. When you start out as a producer, you have to be careful. Everyone around you is very confident that they know the answers, but they usually don't. You have to try things one after the other and see what works (or learn from those who have done it before you - David).


Karen and I had the good luck to move back to the country just as the" Emu Bubble" of the 1990s was bursting. This example of well-publicized, confident predictions being based on nothing but self-delusion was an eye-opener for us, and made us a lot more skeptical of a lot of the other stuff we were hearing.
(Reminds me of today's economical and political climate - David)


We stumbled onto the secret of quality in eggs more or less by accident.
We knew we liked the idea of free range. But, at the time, there was little information on the topic, and most of it was by enthusiastic newbies a la the "emu dudes."
Fortunately, we have excellent library skills and knew that free-range had been the norm way back when. So we spent a lot of time in Oregon State University's library and researched the methods of way back when.


This taught us how to do free range properly -- with portable houses that you move when the hens destroy the nearby grass. This is essential. Permanently sited houses are totally impractical for grass-fed eggs.


What our reading didn't tell us was that grass-fed eggs tasted a lot better than other eggs. In fact, our reading sort of implied that it was the other way around. A hundred years ago, "real farm eggs" meant the same thing as "stale, possibly rotten eggs shipped by slow, unrefrigerated freight."


Quality eggs were raised close to town to reduce shipping time, by hens in confinement or barren yards. So in the old days, because of the lack of refrigeration, confinement eggs were considered good and farm eggs were bad.
(There were some notable exceptions, of course, but it serves to illustrate the point. - David)


Well, we've got refrigerators now, and things are back the way you'd expect. Grass-fed hens get a lot of value out of forage, just like grass-fed beef, and it shows up in the flavor and nutrition of the eggs. This is not too surprising, since up until around 1960 our general knowledge of poultry nutrition was sufficiently poor that many commercial breeders kept their breeder flocks on grass pasture. The superior nutrition resulted in higher hatchability and healthier chicks. But the link to superior flavor wasn't obvious until we started getting grass-fed eggs of our own.


And that's where quality comes from. It comes from keeping your eyes open, trying things one after the other, doing side-by-side tests, and always staying open to the possibility that everyone is nuts but you. Or possibly the other way around.


Keep on trying, keep on testing, and eventually you'll stumble onto something good. If you stay in the biz long enough (any biz), this will happen over and over again, and everyone will think you're a genius. They'll be right, too.
- - Bob Plamondon



Visit our man Bob, "the Genius," Plamondon at www.plamondon.com
 
Last edited:
I admit that I have never had a grass-fed chicken egg cross my lips. I'm expecting the difference to be light night and day. Much like a homegrown tomato versus those store-bought pinkish balls of cardboard.
 
Quote:
Well they are something along those lines.

There is a difference, but it may not be as pronounced as we build it up to be. After all, we have reasons to tout the fresh egg - we are invested in them. I mean, how would it seem if we didn't extol their grand virtues?

But my first experience with a "yard egg" was more about texture than an overwhelming flood of blissful taste, my every taste bud dancing in uncontrollable ecstasy.

Honestly, it tasted like an egg. Sorry, but there it is.

It was a bit more "eggy," perhaps. But most noticeable to me was the decidedly different texture and color of the yolk.
 
The eggs from our hens taste WAY better than any we got from the freerange eggs at the farmers market and night and day above anything from the store. I can definitely tell a difference - can't even order eggs out any more.
 
I am expecting nothing less than a tastebud egg-splosion when I finally get an egg out of my cooky chickens! For all the anticipation and headache of coop building I DESERVE it!
tongue.png
 
For those of us with stationary coops, what would you suggest in terms of getting great tasting "quality" eggs?

I offer my chickens greens, veggies, and grass clippings daily, but free-ranging or a tractor coop is not a viable option in my very small, urban backyard.

Common sense tells me that chickens who get fresh air, sunshine, and clean food and water should produce a quality egg and most of the science involved just overcomplicates a very simple exploit. I don't have an "ideal" set-up, I suppose, but they seem happy and healthy to me.
 
Quote:
See, now, there you go... good, common sense prevails.

Remember, Mr Plamondon is essentially re-creating the range methods of a century ago. It is something he has the space and desire for. He is not, I repeat NOT, condemning those who cannot do it his way. I know Bob - and that 'aint him.

But as you suggest, the wise person listens and learns. To quote Mr. P:

...And that's where quality comes from. It comes from keeping your eyes open, trying things one after the other, doing side-by-side tests, and always staying open to the possibility that everyone is nuts but you. Or possibly the other way around.

Keep on trying, keep on testing, and eventually you'll stumble onto something good.


When you cannot range them, as in your case, you do the next best thing. Clean, uncrowded chickens, fed a diet which includes greens, is as close as you can get to range fed birds. And in this case, close enough will do.

Have you ever heard of a man named Charles Weeks? He did it just your way a very long time ago, with great success. I think you will like your eggs just fine.
 
Last edited:
Quote:
Well they are something along those lines.

There is a difference, but it may not be as pronounced as we build it up to be. After all, we have reasons to tout the fresh egg - we are invested in them. I mean, how would it seem if we didn't extol their grand virtues?

But my first experience with a "yard egg" was more about texture than an overwhelming flood of blissful taste, my every taste bud dancing in uncontrollable ecstasy.

Honestly, it tasted like an egg. Sorry, but there it is.

It was a bit more "eggy," perhaps. But most noticeable to me was the decidedly different texture and color of the yolk.

I am an old woman who has eaten store bought eggs and chickens most of her life. I've had chickens nearly two years now. Also kept them one year about 20 years ago, another year about 30 years ago, and ate plenty of backyard chickens and eggs as a child; in all those earlier situations, we assumed one had to eat them all before winter set in, as that's the "way it was done."

After my childhood, I had no problem eating the eggs, but I could not bring myself to eat the meat after I processed it. Now I let my son and family have the meat (I have no problem helping process) and hard boil the eggs for egg salad or deviled. I used to love fried eggs over easy, but still cannot do it with my own eggs. The difference in the color of the yolk is part of it, I am sure, but there is also an earthiness, or something, to the taste of the egg that gets to me.

Yes, I know this is ridiculous. Yes, I am trying to acclimate myself to this excellent food. Yes, I know the problem is between my ears, not in my taste buds. And, yes, it sure is great to know those yolks won't break when I flip the egg.

Aaaarrrggghhh........
 
Quote:
I'm thinking you should put some dark chocolate on your egg. Or hot fudge syrup.
celebrate.gif


Oh, everyone wrinkles their noses, but you guys KNOW someone has tried it and LOVED it!
love.gif
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom