Yep, ask a hundred people and you'll get a hundred answers! I'd suggest making sure that whatever you get can withstand your average climate. Small combed birds do well if you often get freezing temperatures...
The questions you need to ask yourself have already been asked...purpose, space, etc. In the end, it's all about what appeals to you. I love my Buff and Light Brahmas, but talk about being able to track in poop - those feathered feet are wonderful against our cold Wyoming winters but not so good for keeping clean nesting boxes sometimes! They also tend to accumulate poop on their behind fluff. <sigh> But they're so pretty, nice meaty birds at maturity, and reliable layers of nice big brown eggs. So I put up with the poop and occasionally clip the excess fluff from their behinds.