Who laid this egg?

[KrazyChickenLady13]

Hi everybody! We just got OUR FIRST EGG!!!
Now I’m wondering who laid it, we have 5 birds at laying age(but I refuse to consider a 19 week old silkie laid an egg) 3 barred rocks and an Easter egger. I think it could be our one Easter egger or our verrry dark barred rock.

The birds in question.

also would this egg be considered pink or brown?

 

[sassychickens76]

Looks like my Cochin Bantam eggs, though I know you don't have any.

 

[KrazyChickenLady13]

Looks like my Cochin Bantam eggs, though I know you don't have any.

What color eggs do your Cochins lay?

 

[sassychickens76]

Brown, sometimes they have speckles, one hen lays darker colored eggs that the other two.

 

[aart]

Both of those birds look 'ready'.
You might have to catch them in the act or......
https://www.backyardchickens.com/articles/who-is-laying-and-who-is-not-butt-check.73309/

 

[MamaLynn23]

I would say the Barred Rock. That is exactly like what ur BR girls lay. Two of make that pinky-brown and the other one does a nice medium-dark brown with specks.

 

[Justicedog]

I'd vote for the barred rock too.

 

[FatChicksDigMe]

Did we find out who did it? Lol