Thanks for the opinions! My other two Blrw pullets are 31 weeks, so they didn't grow up together for direct comparison. The pointed appearing feathers in the saddle are actually round feathers with pointy lacing. I know that pic didn't demonstrate it very well, but the actual feathers are round. I know I should be able to tell by now! Wyandottes give me a tough time b/c they are so big and their combs redden early. One of my pullets everyone said was a roo, but I said I would wait to be sure, and yesterday she gave me her first egg! I am actually now leaning pullet for this one, I just feel like a roo would be more obvious by now.