Your going to love them both but the Cayuga if like the one I adopted your going to love her personality, this one named Olive that came to live with us in Jan is so laid back. I love her quack too. It's so cute when everyone lines up to go to the upper part of their property Olive is always last not becasue she Has something wrong she is likes to stop and smell the roses on the way upthey are coming tomorrow! so eggciting!