Excellent article, enjoyable to read. I appreciate that you shared pros and cons of each method. This year I let my hen do ALL of the work, even though she separated herself from the flock, stole a nest outside of the fenced area and hatched them in a storm! She insisted on rejoining the flock with them during the first week, so I decided to again trust her judgement. She is a great mom and has even started allowing a few the Murray McMurray chicks (they are about 4 weeks older than her chicks) to roost with her as well. She keeps her babies on one side and the bigger MM chicks on the other side of her. (Maybe to add another layer of protection for her babies?)