He appears to have a modified pea comb which would have me questioning if he was pure Ameraucana because they theoretically should be homogenous for pea combs… He isn’t a good quality Ameraucana regardless. His comb is out of standard and lopped and his type is poor. Temperament can be genetic...
I can understand that thought process but note the walnut comb and fibro skin (also evident with the blue earlobe). Silkies are also often bearded. If you crossed a pea-combed EE with a Cochin, all offspring would either have modified pea combs or single combs. A walnut comb wouldn’t occur. All...
She looks to be what people call “Zombies” or “Pearl Onyx.” Your other one is definitely crossed with Silkie (note fibro-skin and walnut comb). She could be part Cochin as well but I’m also potentially seeing vulture hocks. She might be a multi-generational mix