I am unconcerned with the breed or breed type since the OP is going for a mixed flock anyway. But if someone wanted a pure flock, then #2 would be by far the best choice. For me it was almost a toss up between 1 and 2 anyway. But #1 has proven that he takes care of his girls and is very sweet to...
For all the reasons above, I'd go with #1. He has proven to be the best for the flock and if he only bit you once, just the other day, then he's not a mean guy and can be brought around, in my opinion.