Sneaky is aptly named! Still not sure, but on the 5th pic down (side view of tail), does anyone see saddle feathers? Is that a row of thin feathers just above Sneaky's wing? The comb is confusing too! I'll be interested to see what everyone thinks!
I remember Gravie! Thought of her(?) when I saw Sneaky. Long lost twins, aren't they! Both have those big legs too. My EE pullet did as well, and she grew into them. I think she weighs more than my Buff Orp or Australorp! Still leaning toward pullet for both of yours!
Just saw this thread tonight. What an interesting EE you have! Not obvious one way or another.
I think Sneaky is a tomboy!!!
Well, really either a late developing cockerel or a boyish pullet. If forced to choose, I would say pullet due to the even color pattern. Will be interesting to see...