Thanks for the encouragement - she is totally smooth (almost fully feathered out if not completely). It's just the comb that worries me, nothing else (attitude is definitely not what I'd expect from a roo) and then seeing that pic on Page 8 of a 5-week-old roo really got me excited Gwen is...
No I ordered 1 GC pullet. So no others to compare her to besides the other chicks growing...her comb is about the same size as our BO "pullets" but seems slightly darker.
Great to find this thread - I asked on the What Breed or Gender thread about our GC Gwen, who just recently I thought might be a roo due to her comb coming in (she's 4 weeks, 5 days old in this pic). What do you guys think? The pics on Pg. 8 for the 5 week old GC Roo has me feeling a bit better...