I completely agree on the yellow skin. I would not use one with yellow skin. And if you are choosing them now, I'd also not necessarily keep the light eyed boy. They do not always pass on to the offspring, but you will get some like that on occasion. Although Suede's eyes are too light, I chose...
Katy, # 8 has the golden brown eyes as opposed to dark brown, he is a beauty, but his eyes are not as desirable as the darker brown. Suede also has lighter eyes, but his ladies have very dark brown. Eye color isn't the hardest thing to overcome, but they say go for body type first, then eye...
They are all nice, but I'd say #5 over #4 due to #4 having a longer back and #5 has nicer lacing. I like him. I'm no good at this, Katy-I love them all too much! I also like #6. How many are you keeping?