8.5 week Icelandic/Wyandotte genders?

[slg2007]

I have 3 chicks, 8.5 weeks old that I am having a hard time deciding on gender. My neighbor gave me these hatching eggs and her roosters were all Icelandic and her hens are various Wyandottes. So here are the three. I feel confident the darkest brown one is a pullet. The cream and gold ones are the trickier two.

View attachment 1163707

 

[AlleysChicks]

White and black and the red are males. Unsure of the dark one but leaning towards pullet for now.

 

[ChattyChickens4Life]

Red and black are cockerels, I think. Possibly the white one, but I'm not too sure.

 

[Crazy for Chickens!]

Could you get a pic of each chick's comb? Thanks!

 

[JedJackson]

Pic 1- cockerel
Pic 2- pullet
Pic 3- likely a cockerel.

What an interesting mix. Icelandics are wonderful chickens.

 

[drumstick diva]

Icelandic breeders do NOT mix them with other breeds. Please check out the "Icelandic thread."

 

[slg2007]

Updated pics at 12 weeks....any new insights? Still thinking the red one is a cockerel but the other two could be pullets??

 

[slg2007]

Icelandic breeders do NOT mix them with other breeds. Please check out the "Icelandic thread."

Is it against the law or something? She has some mixes and some pure.

 

[AlleysChicks]

Dark in the middle is pullet. Other 2 are cockerels

 

[junebuggena]

Two cockerels and one pullet. Notice how both of the boys have the same shade of red through the wing/shoulder, even though they have very different colorings? That's a male specific trait.