We'll have to agree to disagree. I think the argument against their plan for getting chickens is very sound. The OP may not have thought about all the pros and cons.advice is always good, and I agree, they may do better with less. But my point is simply that encouraging or suggesting "no chickens" isn't very helpful advice if OP wants them and can find a way to keep them practically. It might not be about just what they can get out of the birds- poultry are fun to keep and can be enjoyable to be around
It's no different than us giving advice on a coop someone purchased that is way too small or poorly built. It's advice. It's up to the OP to do with said advice as they choose.