Depending on the market in your area.....depends on how good a deal you got. The fact you didn't get what you paid for is the main issue "in my personal opinion". At least you did get pullets, that's a plus. In my neck of the woods they'd be $7-$8 pullets. I'd let the seller know that they are in fact not selling Ameraucanas, but Easter Eggers. The fact alone that they aren't bearded proves they aren't Ameraucanas. Little lone the other major factors. In fact just by looking at these pictures they may not even be Easter Eggers, they may just be crossbred barnyard birds.