I'm a beek as well! I have a hive and I used the Longstroth hive this year. It was my first hive, and it's been an amazing experience! The more everyone else here in CO complained about how terrible their crops were the better mine seemed to be doing! I had a bumper crop of everything from beans to corn to squash. I've found it hard to deal with some of the hard core clubs, they want you to pay all this money to be a member, I've found a TON of support and help online. The Bee Source website is awesome. Really great people willing to help.
I took a med super of honey this year, and left 2 deep for the bees. Next year I'm really interested in trying a top bar hive. It turns out I'm pretty allergic to bees, which has been a sever bummer, but I have found that the only times I really take stings is when I am not paying attention out in the garden and sit on a bee or weed without gloves or something equally not smart. I'm not letting it deter me and I'm going full steam ahead with at least one more hive next year, I hope they overwinter well, I believe that will be the case as my hive is very strong and I got my bees from a 40+ yr beek who is out here in CO, I advise if you are going to buy a Pac or a Nuc of bees, then get it from a local well respected source with strong bees for your climate.
Lisa