black barred plymouth rocks - 2 males?

[col2e2n]

My husband and I started out with 3 black barred plymouth rock chicks (they are now almost 5 months old). We determined the one is a male, due to his comb, and he went away.

Now, we are down to two, and I am torn between thinking that they are 1 hen and 1 rooster (as a friend guessed) or 2 roosters.

I would be grateful for any insights you can provide, as we live in the city, and the crowing has commenced (although I can never catch them in the act face to face!).

They are usually both in the coop, but Chicken #2 is in the garage for photo purposes, and so I can keep them straight!

Chicken 1:

Chicken 2:

 

[paddock36]

Roosters for sure.

 

[Cuban Longtails]

Yup, for sure those are both very male chickens.

 

[rodriguezpoultry]

I see hen shopping in your future! Both are males!

 

[krazycow6]

Both definately roosters

 

[Pampered Hen]

You have yourself two very handsome boys.

 

[chickenshagg]

I bought 4 barred rock pullets and ended up with three roosters and one hen. They look just like my three 4 month old barred rock roosters that are just starting to crow(almost).

 

[barred-rocks-rock]

both boys. by the way? does anyone have campine egg pictures?

 

[chickenshagg]

Here is a photo of my barred rock hen and my roosters. The hen is darker and has a very short comb.

 

[krazycow6]

They are GORGEOUS!! but male sorry