Blue Andalusian or Silver Laced Wyandotte?

[MrsCait]

unfortunately I only have one really awful photo of them, I'll take more in the daylight soon.

I just got 2 chicks hatched 5/23 from a feed store locally. One was sold to be a Blue Andalusian and the other was sold as a Silver Laced Wyandotte(I'm pretty sure). I can't remember which one she told me was which, and they look so similar! How can I tell? I feel like I might not even be able to tell until one lays white and one lays brown eggs haha.

The only difference I really notice is one has a comb and the other doesn't. I did buy them "sexed" female, but I know that's not 100% I thought blue Andalusians generally have large combs so that's why I thought maybe she was that one. She is more slender looking and slightly lighter.

The other one has a strange colored beak, it's kind of mottled? Darker colored head. Much more vocal than any of my other chicks.

Are there signs that would show the different traits between the breeds? Again, I'll post better photos soon, sorry. Just tell me what to take pictures of so I can help you guess the best.

 

[chickendreams24]

Neither of those chicks appear to be feathering in like a SLW and both appear blue. Better photos in natural light of head shots as well as body shots of them standing naturally may help identify them. Also include photos that show their leg color.

 

[Sneebsey]

Agreed; neither are silver laced wyandottes, they have a very different pattern to these two. The one on the left of the picture is your andalusian. A standing photo of the other chick, from the side, as @chickendreams24 suggests, along with a picture of its comb would help identify it.

 

[ButtonquailGirl14]

it does look like 2 blue birds, no lacing.

 

[MrsCait]

Is there such thing as a blue wyandotte?

I could have been mistaken when she told me the breed, but that name "Wyandotte" sounds accurate. I'm 99% sure she said Blue Andalusian and ...something.... Wyandotte. I'll go take pictures this morning.

 

[Sneebsey]

There are Blue Wyandottes, yes. If it has yellow legs and a rose comb, it could be a Blue Wyandotte.

 

[BlackHackle]

Too stubby to be young Blue Andalusians

 

[drumstick diva]

too young

 

[ButtonquailGirl14]

Is there such thing as a blue wyandotte?

I could have been mistaken when she told me the breed, but that name "Wyandotte" sounds accurate. I'm 99% sure she said Blue Andalusian and ...something.... Wyandotte. I'll go take pictures this morning.

there are blue laced red wydottes, yellow legs and pea comb?

 

[ButtonquailGirl14]

Too stubby to be young Blue Andalusians

this guy knows what he is talking about. so maybe they aren't?