Bought as Ameraucana but it doesn’t look like others

[clamccauley]

I bought two identical chicks that I was told were Ameraucauna. One looks like one but the other now is white with a lot of random black markings. What do you think it is? Rooster?
It’s the black and white one in front. The one behind it was the one identical as a chick.

 

[Gray Farms]

They are Easter Eggers

 

[cstephens1987]

Well for starters they're both actually Easter Eggers, not Ameraucana (this is pretty typical though).
You'll also want to get some clearer closer pics, and tell us how old they are.
From these pics they appear to be pullets but will need better pictures and age to see if that can be determined.

As far as them looking different...that's the beautiful thing about Easter Eggers. They all do! They're a lovely gorgeous mutt of a chicken and as such come in a kaleidescope of colors and patterns and behavior

 

[Frazzemrat1]

Agreed, I see two easter eggers

 

[Brahma Chicken5000]

Both are Easter Eggers. How old are they? Better pictures are needed to identify gender.

 

[chrissynemetz]

I agree with everyone else, I believe you have two Easter Eggers