Hey. Actual comments on actual breeding...
Their needs and what is ideal does change with time. It is interesting to hear your observations with your own birds.
Even with poultry, they are the most efficient when they are at their best.
It is interesting to hear the markedly different results that you did realize with the different matings, and your plan to move forward.
Your plan with your experiences is a model for others to follow. To secure the best stock that we can. Something deep enough to start with. Either two pairs or one trio. Go in some different directions, and focus on what does work best.
Then you have narrowed your focus, which we have to do. And that can change from year to year, according to what we are seeing. Heck, sometimes we have to set a side pen up to work on something separate from the main effort. Not getting too complicated, but not to the neglect of something that we will pay for later either.
You will do well if you choose. I hope that others consider your example, and establish a model that aligns with these fundamentals. It is helpful for me to be reminded of them....
It has been interesting to work through all that it has required to just get started. The most rare and challenging breeds really should not be everyone's starting place. There really is value in considering a breed and variety in better shape, and simpler to start. There is nothing wrong with white Leghorns or Rocks. LOL.
Thank you, sir, I value your opinion.
I have saved one nice Blue cockerel, and am still evaluating 3 Red pullets. I may cross them with each other for a purple family, or backcross the cockerel to his dam and the pullets to their non-sire. (as luck would have it, all my Blue family pullets were either black laced or gold instead of red.)
Dfr1973, those hideous very slow feathering chicks threw me for a loop. I planned to cull runts, but wound up culling mostly for nudity instead. I even had a feather-legged pullet, lol! If either of next year's families show the same problems I had this year, I will cull the common parent, for sure! When those recessive surprises are less frequent, I will be able to better focus on production.