Well, I never ordered direct from Ideal but that's where one of my favorite feed stores gets chicks from. I bought my Barred Rocks and Leghorns from that same feed store and they turned out good in my opinion. The only negative thing I can say about Ideal was that I ordered 9 White Leghorns through the feed store and two of them had black flecks in their feathering. I did a little research on Ideal's site and under their White Leghorn listing it says they reserve the right to substitute California Whites for White Leghorns unless you specifically state not to allow substitutions. Had I known this I would've said only send White Leghorns. The California Whites turned out really good but I just don't like the idea of them substituting since specific breeds matter to me since I live in an extreme climate and I researched the best breeds accordingly. MM has the same language about substitutions on their website so for my October order I checked off the box not to allow substitutions because I specifically want Brown Leghorns, Naked Necks, Dark Cornish, and the Cornish Crosses and nothing else. I even turned down the bonus chick because I'm not interested in anything but what I ordered. I probably could've taken the bonus chick and just ate him, but with my luck they'd probably send me a bantam Leghorn or something that wouldn't be worth the trouble of raising and cooking.