Can anyone identify this "extra" from Holderreads?

Discussion in 'Ducks' started by galgo98, Sep 9, 2011.

  1. galgo98

    galgo98 Songster

    May 9, 2011
    Lebanon, Pennsylvania
    I ordered 10 deluxe runners from Holderreads this spring. I received 10 plus 1 "extra" the end of April. At first, I assumed that the extra was another runner. As a duckling, she stood upright like the runners, but as she got older, you could tell she was stretching to stay as tall as them. She was also not able to run as fast as them, so she flies to keep up now. She has always been a little different (much smarter) than the runners. You can see her process information and solve problems. The runners get to the fence, run into fence, back up, run into fence again, back up, run into fence again, ok fence is there, now what do we do. Whereas, "extra" sees 2' chicken wire fence, looks up at fence, looks side to side to see if she can go around fence, backs up and flies over fence (I need to clip her wing). I feel bad for her because she is often off by herself. I would like to get her some ducks she can relate to, but I'm not sure what breed she is. I've tried to contact Holderread's several times (after the shipping season) with no response. I had double checked under the lid of the shipping box and it just says 1 "extra". I wouldn't think Holderread's would have mixed ducks (I guess anything can happen!), but she doesn't resemble any of the breeds on their website. Can anybody identify my little "extra". Her name is Greg Louganis, she was the first in the pond and would constantly dive around underwater. We were convinced that this devilish little duckling was a boy....

    The little grey/blue one on the right is Greg.



    This is her pretending to be a runner duck.
    Last edited: Sep 9, 2011
  2. jdywntr

    jdywntr Songster

    Oct 31, 2009
    Somerville, AL
    Looks like a poorly bred runner to me. The head is the same. Except for the carriage, looks runner. Wouldn't think you would get that from Holderreads but I've never ordered from them. She's pretty. Just don't breed her. Maybe a mix but again, I would not think that that would be a possibility from them.
  3. DaughterOfEve

    DaughterOfEve Songster

    Sep 3, 2009
    Montague, MI
    Got me! maybe someone else will be along to help.
  4. galgo98

    galgo98 Songster

    May 9, 2011
    Lebanon, Pennsylvania
    I'm not planning on incubating anytime soon... We wanted them for all of the slugs in the backyard and for table eggs. I was hoping we will be able to tell her eggs apart from the others based on size if we do decide to incubate. However, they just started laying this week and all the eggs so far are small! [​IMG] And of course, the best looking drake prefers Greg over the "upright" girls... [​IMG]
  5. desertdarlene

    desertdarlene Crowing

    Aug 4, 2010
    San Diego
    The head looks runnerish, so I agree about the poor quality runner. That might be why they gave her away as an "extra".
  6. Dusky Beauty

    Dusky Beauty Songster

    Aug 11, 2011
    Upshur County, Texas
    She looks kinda like my khaki campbells, and acts like them too.
  7. lilchick

    lilchick Songster

    May 23, 2008
    Williamsport In.
    looks like a blue cayuga to me.
  8. GrannyCarol

    GrannyCarol Chirping

    Jul 7, 2011
    Since they carry Dusky Dutch Hookbills, I wonder if that is what it is? I looked at a few pictures and some of them are more hooked than your duck, but some of them aren't so much. They don't mention Blue Cayugas on their website. The shape and carriage are not right at all for a Runner and the Holderread's breed some really nice ducks on the whole. I've gotten quite a few from them and the quality is always good. The Cayugas I've known are more substantial than that duck.

    Here's the Hookbill page on one of my favorite sites for duck info:
  9. Miss Lydia

    Miss Lydia Loving this country life

    That would be so cool if she is a hookbill. but what ever she is "Extra" is beautiful.
  10. bayyjayy

    bayyjayy Songster

    Jul 5, 2011
    I agree, Miss Lydia.....her coloring is amazing!

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: